Login (password reminder?):
islandmix.com register | Connect with Facebook | Support (login probs)

IslandMix - Soca, Reggae, Zouk and Caribbean Entertainment

Reply
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes  
Old 04-13-2004, 10:09 PM   #1 (permalink)
Ball-in-Hand
 
Hotgirl11226's Avatar
Hotgirl11226 is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: NY
Posts: 6,197
Credits: 3,804
Who is more civilized?

A well dressed man with a gun or a half naked man with a stick?

This is a question that we dealt with in my European history class. The topic was European expansionism and at this time of course, the Europeans wanted to conquer the Indians. Their number one justification was to "civilize" the people....So I think to myslef as, I am watching Bush's speach tonight and he just made a comment to justify the war in Iraq and of course what did he say, he felt that we were civilizing them...(among other things).

so what do u think of the question now, are we really civilizing them, hell, are we more civilized as a bunch of bullies with big ass guns???
  Reply With Quote  
Old 04-13-2004, 11:32 PM   #2 (permalink)
xtremeintl.com
 
Mystic Xtremist's Avatar
Mystic Xtremist is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Plugged In From Zion
Posts: 18,241
Credits: 11,425
Re: Who is more civilized?

Originally posted by Hotgirl11226
I am watching Bush's speach tonight and he just made a comment to justify the war in Iraq and of course what did he say, he felt that we were civilizing them...

no no no....tell me he cyaar be dat stupid....no no he cyaar be dat idiotic to utter that word.....i'm actually shocked.....thanks Bush, I now have all the evidence I'll ever need to place u in the annals of Columbus, the religious missionaries, and all the other great murderous colonizers, "civilizers", and cleansers of history.....boi u really are dumb.

As for your question hotgirl, the answer always depends on who's telling the story, who's answering the question...which is typically the self-proclaimed well-dressed colonizer.

But in my opinion, whoever wants to take the word of a mass murderer as to what it means to be civilized....hey, go right ahead.
  Reply With Quote  
Sponsored Links
Old 04-13-2004, 11:48 PM   #3 (permalink)
MLO, CTA 4 LIFE
 
Kamasutra's Avatar
Kamasutra is offline
 
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: planet venus
Posts: 7,655
Credits: 1,746
Re: Who is more civilized?

Originally posted by Hotgirl11226
A well dressed man with a gun or a half naked man with a stick?

This is a question that we dealt with in my European history class. The topic was European expansionism and at this time of course, the Europeans wanted to conquer the Indians. Their number one justification was to "civilize" the people....So I think to myslef as, I am watching Bush's speach tonight and he just made a comment to justify the war in Iraq and of course what did he say, he felt that we were civilizing them...(among other things).

so what do u think of the question now, are we really civilizing them, hell, are we more civilized as a bunch of bullies with big ass guns???
Who defines civilization ...or is that one culture that attempts to dictate to another that thier society is better or one to be assimilated to? As you know.. the American civilization had it's genisis in Europe and subsequently after setting foot in America, they soon resorted to 'civilizing' the Indians and we all know that such resulted in taking over their territory and ultimately as some form of penance provided the indians pieces of land (reservations)....could you fathom that any other country would dear to invade or come to America and dictate it's policies or society is supreme and the one to conform....
  Reply With Quote  
Old 04-13-2004, 11:53 PM   #4 (permalink)
where de crix
 
Oneshot's Avatar
Oneshot is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: UK
Posts: 16,857
Credits: 24,373
Re: Who is more civilized?

Originally posted by Hotgirl11226
A well dressed man with a gun or a half naked man with a stick?

This is a question that we dealt with in my European history class. The topic was European expansionism and at this time of course, the Europeans wanted to conquer the Indians. Their number one justification was to "civilize" the people....So I think to myslef as, I am watching Bush's speach tonight and he just made a comment to justify the war in Iraq and of course what did he say, he felt that we were civilizing them...(among other things).

so what do u think of the question now, are we really civilizing them, hell, are we more civilized as a bunch of bullies with big ass guns???
hotgirl, i got an iraqi fren, and he protrayed his country has a group of nationalists royal to their country and their leader (religious, political, or family) so they will fight against anyone who does not match with their views.. and they stick together like de buttom of a shoe to glue..

he for example had some bad blood with a couple korean guys (a year old) he called an arabic fren.. in about 15mins dey were bout 50 cars.. approx 100 arabs.. more than half of them he did not kno.. ready and willing to beat the $hit out the korean guys.. which they did.. which is civil to them.. cause once you do not disrespect them they do not disrespect you.. and setting up a government that has no street respect.. to rule a nation.. that is disrespect.. not speaking admirably about their religious leaders that is disrespect..

they may hate each other.. but they got one common enemy (socio 101.. us vs them)
  Reply With Quote  
Old 04-13-2004, 11:57 PM   #5 (permalink)
What line in the sand?
 
D' Silent Type's Avatar
D' Silent Type is offline
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: On borrowed time I didn't even ask to borrow.
Posts: 84
Credits: 128
Re: Who is more civilized?

Originally posted by Hotgirl11226
A well dressed man with a gun or a half naked man with a stick?

This is a question that we dealt with in my European history class. The topic was European expansionism and at this time of course, the Europeans wanted to conquer the Indians. Their number one justification was to "civilize" the people....So I think to myslef as, I am watching Bush's speach tonight and he just made a comment to justify the war in Iraq and of course what did he say, he felt that we were civilizing them...(among other things).

so what do u think of the question now, are we really civilizing them, hell, are we more civilized as a bunch of bullies with big ass guns???
When Civilization Began...(500,000 years ago)

...Man eats, has sex, works, operates in his tribe, fights other human beings for rich lands bountiful in food and game or for strategic purposes, and dies.

In the year 2004...

...Man eats, has sex, works, operates in his tribe (Oh, I mean nation), fights other human beings for rich lands bountiful in natural resources (oil, coal, uranium, etc.) or strategic purposes and dies.

The only difference in 2004 is that we fight each other with bullets, missiles, shells, and threaten each other with global destruction...10 times over. And the complex burecratic and social structure behind modern socities that make things more complex and complicated, but essentiallly things remain the same. It always has and always will.

"Civilized", since colonialization always meant "Democratized". According to the West, the best government is a democracy, which apparently allows citizens with a lot of rights (or the impression of them) and free economic development (exploitation). However, if my study of governments serves me correctly, no government on this earth truly is a democracy (all citizens do not have a direct say in government, which is the point of democracy). What we have in the west is a more burecratic system where we trust the bureaucracy and the chosen few to deal with everything while we toddle on with our lives. So the idea is to repeat this everywhere else in the world that does not have it, with the only people posing any serious resistance is China.

Oh, one more thing, just to show you how civilized George Bush's America is, take a look at this footage. Real civilized for sure. Click on the link and judge for yourselves.
http://www.bullshido.net/modules.php...download&cid=6
  Reply With Quote  
Old 04-14-2004, 12:09 AM   #6 (permalink)
Ball-in-Hand
 
Hotgirl11226's Avatar
Hotgirl11226 is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: NY
Posts: 6,197
Credits: 3,804
Re: Re: Who is more civilized?

Originally posted by D' Silent Type
Civilized", since colonialization always meant "Democratized".
listening to replays of Bush's speech on the news now, i realize how many time Bush referes to America as "the civilized"...it just irks me...cause who the hell are we to deem others uncivilized?
  Reply With Quote  
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread: