![]() |
|
|
#1 (permalink) |
|
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Brooklyn
Posts: 421
Credits: 1,661
|
U.S.Rael
Very interesting article exploring the similarities (historically) behind U.S. Nationalism in the West and Zionism in the Middle East. Both ideologies oppressive in nature and are now entwined. What is usually untold is that early Zionism considered proposals circa 1917 for Argentina and then Uganda to be “their holy grounds”. So a claim that Palestine was anointed by God for them is hypocritical. It was really which ever land that was strategically within their “cross hairs”
Excerpts: Like the US, Israel would be unique in its democratic institutions, its multicultural society and its modernity. Israel would also, like the US, apply the most advanced technology in the resolution of existential problems and towards the achievement of a high standard of living. … Recently the work of John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt has raised the question of how Israel, through the Zionist lobby in the US, has perhaps come to exercise a virtually direct control over US policy in the Middle East. This is an important debate in which others, such as Noam Chomsky and Bill and Kathleen Christison have made important contributions. In this debate, in my opinion, the cultural connections between Zionism and the United States should not be minimized. … When we speak of the colonizers, of America and Palestine, it is logical to forget the indigenous inhabitants of both places, for it was the land that was colonized--not the people living on it. … In some significant ways, US nationalism is linked to, or seen as having affinities with Jewish nationalism as represented first by the Zionist movement and then by the Israeli state. It is why Israel is not seen in the United States as an alien culture in the Middle East, but rather as an extension of American historical experience. It is perhaps in this cultural-ontological sense that Israel is the "51st state" (and not primarily because of the extensive economic, financial and military ties). http://www.counterpunch.org/portis02242007.html |
|
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|


Thread Tools
Rate Thread
Display Modes

Linear Mode