Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 16 to 22 of 22

Thread: Federation of the West Indies: Its collapse and failure

  1. #16
    Banned Rory is offline
    Join Date
    Nov 2003


    Source: Skylark


    By Caldwell Taylor

    "In a divided world that don't need islands no more,
    Are we doomed for ever to be at somebody's mercy?"
    David Rudder: "Rally Round the West Indies"

    Austin "Mighty Skylark" Tuitt, a Brooklyn ( New York)- based cleric and calypsonian, is preaching a gospel of Caribbean unity. This is by no means a new gospel, for the idea of a single Caribbean nation is something that has taxed the political imagination of the so-called "English speaking Caribbean" for more than a century. It is an idea that is at once a logical response to the tyrannies of both geography and history, and a struggle against the evils of more than five centuries of foreign domination. Though it faces many formidable odds, Tuitt's ministry of unity is another hopeful beginning that is unashamedly inspired by the 1958 West Indies Federation.

    Everybody knows that the 10-member West Indies Federation (Antigua-Barbuda, Barbados, Dominica, Grenada, Jamaica, Montserrat, St Kitts-Nevis, St Lucia, St Vincent and Trinidad-Tobago) did not last as long as the proverbial Red House fire. Launched on April 22,1958 the much- heralded experiment in regional integration came undone in September 1961, in the wake of Jamaica's decision to pullout and go it alone. Jamaica's decision to leave prompted Eric Williams (1911-1981) to propound his new arithmetic. "One from 10 leaves nought", deadpanned the then Premier of Trinidad and Tobago. The collapse of the Federation dealt a crushing blow to the fragile psychologies of ten small islands which sought a collective path out of British trusteeship, but it was not enough, mercifully, to cancel the dream of a single Caribbean

    And so within three years of the May 31, 1962 dissolution of the Federation CARIFTA ( the Caribbean Free Trade Association) was inaugurated by Antigua , Barbados and Guyana. By August 1968 CARIFTA hosted the ten islands that once made up the ill-starred West Indies Federation plus Guyana. (You will recall that Guyana ,then known as British Guiana, British Honduras, now Belize, The Bahamas, Bermuda, Turks and Caicos, the Caymans and the British Virgin Islands all refused to answer the British Colonial Secretary Arthur Creech Jones's call for a "federation in the Caribbean, enjoying internal self-government within the British Commonwealth"). CARIFTA grew into CARICOM (1973), and a little more than thirty years later CARICOM continues to be a major institutional expression of this ancient dream that is meant to rescue us from our stifling insularities.

    Why the West Indies Federation collapsed is not a matter within the scope of this essay. But even so, it is well worth noting that many have asserted that, the failure of the 1950s federal enterprise had much to do with top-down architecture imposed on the union by its British principals. Orders, these critics say, came from the British Colonial Office, which backed federation only because it was a means of administrative economy.

    The opponents of top-down federalism propose a bottom -up alternative. In other words, a federation that is driven by what economist C.Y Thomas has described as " a resolute and relentless pursuit of the interests of the poor and powerless".
    Thomas and other exponents of the bottom-up approach say integration will succeeed only to the extent to which it finds favour with internal social (class) forces in the region. Calypsonian "Atilla the Hun" (1892-1962) anticipated Thomas and company, when he captured the flavour of this 'popular' brand of federation in a 1933 song entitled "Expedite Federation". He sang:

    We know that federation means Emancipation So let us start to co-operate, agitate and educate.

    The second line of Attila's couplet was borrowed from T. A. Marryshow (1887-1958), the widely-acknowledged "Father of West Indian Federation". Always a savvy political actor, Atilla used the word "Emancipation" in his song in order to bring attention to what he viewed as the real purpose of the integrative effort. Besides, he was also drawing attention to the fact of the
    centenary of the abolition of slavery. The bard had such an exquisite historical sense; 'reading' Atilla tells us why the calypsonian is the most organic of our poets and public intellectuals.

    Atilla's interest in Caribbean unity has been embraced by many calypsonians, including Sparrow, King Fighter, Small Island Pride, Melody, Bomber, Chalkdust, Stalin, Valentino, Ipa, David Rudder, and latterly Mighty Skylark Austin Tuitt, founder of the Brooklyn ( New York ) -based Global Caribbean Representation (GCR). The New York birth of the GCR is probably a good omen as New York-based West Indians have played crucial roles in the struggle for Caribbean nationhood.

    Back in the 1930s, New York's West Indies Defence Committee (led by Hope Stevens, Augustin Petioni , Richard Moore, W. Adolphe Roberts, Reginald Pierrepoint and Wilfred.A Domingo, among others) backed the integration efforts at home and provided solid ideological, organizational and financial support for the radical and anti-colonial movements throughout the region. The scholar-activists of the West Indies Defence Committee and the West Indian National Council are among the key builders of a Caribbean intellectual tradition.

    The call to create a single Caribbean nation was the originating theme of the GCR but that was the easy part, for now the organization must go from the call for unity to the realisation of unity in what is doubtless the most 'balkanized region on earth'. How do we attain unity in a region where, according to Christin Girault, "elements of diversity tend to overshadow the trends towards unity"?

    Tuitt and his GCR have their wuk cut out for them: They must help us to understand the historical forces that have balkanized the Caribbean region, and as well they must create the conditions that will help us overcome balkanization and envision a Caribbean citizenship that will include Aruba, Cuba, Haiti, Martinique and the rest of our Caribbean family. This new federation will be based
    on our historical and cultural affinities.

    As a practising calypsonian,Tuitt is well aware of the healing power of music and, in particular, of the calypsonian's historical role as teacher. He must know that the calypso is a true 'pedagogy of the oppressed' , a nationalist poetry that has the power to repatriate alienated souls. Tuitt's recent release of a CD- "Theme Songs for Promoting Global Caribbean Representation" suggests that he plans to use calypso and his Christian faith as his principal instruments of political and moral mobilization.

  2. #17
    Sanity Challenged AXA_Princess's Avatar AXA_Princess is offline
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    in mi house
    Please keep posting articles on this... I have a Caribeban Studies exam next week that I can't seem to study for

  3. #18
    Registered Member VINCYPOWA's Avatar VINCYPOWA is offline
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Quote Originally Posted by Solidarity View Post
    The topic stems from a discussion in the Soca chat forum and i thought it important enough to get it's own thread. Ragga007, thanks for sparking this.
    i admittedly dont know enough about what happened with the Federation to offer a thorough analysis but i've committed myself to doing some research and will certainly be making my contributions shortly.

    In fact i did a search on Imix and found this thread:

    United Islands of the Caribbean???

    Sando, ah callin yuh out...yuh left de business

    Anyway, what do folks think about the Federation and the fact that it didn't survive? Discuss.
    That FELLA was a LEGEND on IMIX.

    Ohhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhh

  4. #19
    Letterist XtasyReds's Avatar XtasyReds is offline
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    Boston, MA
    A next thread with some folks who dont frequent this site anymore.

  5. #20
    Registered User BRIAN is offline
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Quote Originally Posted by VINCYPOWA View Post
    That FELLA was a LEGEND on IMIX.

    Ohhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhh

    What caused the banning attempted coup?

  6. #21
    Registered User Daveed's Avatar Daveed is offline
    Join Date
    Aug 2004

    Thumbs down

    I was with you until you started talking nonsense about "scaled down version of the NEW WORLD ORDER..........what's next implanting barcodes to 'verify your caribbean authenticity'......"

    What does that have to do with what the subject is?
    c'mon guy!!

    Oh to understand I would need to read REVELATIONS - a book full of allegories and mysteries that most theologians don’t fully understand.
    I bet you understand it all though...


    Quote Originally Posted by Know Yuh Culture View Post
    there are alot of factors to take into consideration,

    1) are we talking about the Caribbean presenting a united front, if so Iam all for it.

    2) If we talking about this one government, one currency, one nation vibes..........."READ REVELATIONS"

    I am not for it, how do you acoount for the differences in Currency value to the US Dolar...(to correct some one in here, the Cayman Dollar is higer than the US Dollar)

    Think about it, if the Caribbean becomes one Nation, Criminals now have a wide variety of options after committing their crimes...........Do we really want that?

    How do you get the different economies to exist as one, for example Barbados (Stable) & Guyana (Unstable).

    How do you maintain the individuality that makes each Caribbean Island Unique.....................Now the more than ever we would be feeding the ignorance of the American publice when it comes to the perception of the Caribbean only being Haiti, Jamaica, & The Bahamas.

    In my opinion This is just a scaled down version of the NEW WORLD ORDER..........what's next implanting barcodes to 'verify your caribbean authenticity'......wake up and smell the pot of Coffee.

    I may be biased, so if anyone can outline the benefits or plus to such a move please do so.........
    Last edited by Daveed; 04-30-2007 at 02:16 AM.

  7. #22
    Registered User jonson is offline
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    ST Kitts

    Federation of the West Indies: Its collapse and failure

    Yes, brilliant article. I would love to know more and more about these islands. Dream to be there for lifetime.

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts