IslandMix

Has the 'notion of sin' been lost?
Updated 18h 47m ago | Comments288 | Recommend26 E-mail | Save | Print | Reprints & Permissions | Subscribe to stories like this
Catholics dip their hands into holy water after receiving ashes in observance of Ash Wednesday at The Saint Louis Cathedral in New Orleans, Feb. 6. Ash Wednesday marks the beginning of Lent, which ends on Easter, when it is believed Jesus rose from the dead after dying for their sins. But just what is a sin? Not all Americans agree.
Enlarge image Enlarge By Sean Gardner, AFP/Getty Images
Catholics dip their hands into holy water after receiving ashes in observance of Ash Wednesday at The Saint Louis Cathedral in New Orleans, Feb. 6. Ash Wednesday marks the beginning of Lent, which ends on Easter, when it is believed Jesus rose from the dead after dying for their sins. But just what is a sin? Not all Americans agree.

THE IDEA CLUB
USA TODAY's Cathy Grossman wants to hear from you. Join her weekly discussion on values, religious beliefs and spiritual ideas here.

Pope Benedict XVI
By Marco Di Lauro, Getty Images

WHAT AMERICANS CALL SIN

• Adultery: 81%

• Racism: 74%

• Using "hard" drugs, such as cocaine, LSD: 65%

• Not saying anything if a cashier gives you too much change: 63%

• Having an abortion: 56%

• Homosexual activity or sex: 52%

• Not reporting some income on your tax returns: 52%

• Reading or watching pornography: 50%

• Gossip: 47%

• Swearing: 46%

• Sex before marriage: 45%

• Homosexual thoughts: 44%

• Sexual thoughts about someone you are not married to: 43%

• Doing things as a consumer that harm the environment: 41%

• Smoking marijuana: 41%

• Getting drunk: 41%

• Gambling: 30%

• Not attending church or religious services regularly: 18%

• Drinking any alcohol: 14%

Source: Ellison Research, August 2007, based on 1,007 adults through a representative online panel ad adjusted to be demographically representative of the USA Margin of error: ±3.1 percentage points.

o Yahoo! Buzz
o Digg
o Newsvine
o Reddit
o Facebook
o What's this?

By Cathy Lynn Grossman, USA TODAY
Is sin dead? No, not by a long shot. Yet as Easter approaches, some pastors and theologians worry: How can Christians celebrate Jesus' atonement for their sins and the promise of eternal life in his resurrection if they don't recognize themselves as sinners?

Take it from Pope Benedict XVI. He says the modern world "is losing the notion of sin." And not just personal sins such as greed, lust or the rest of the infamous Seven Deadlies, but social sins, too, such as polluting the planet or allowing injustice to flourish.

RELATED: Vatican updates its thou-shalt-not list
IDEA CLUB: Join the blog discussion: What is a 'new' sin?

Take it from the Rev. Albert Mohler, president of Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, who doesn't give a jelly bean for the modern version of Easter.

"All the Easter eggs and the Easter bunny are even more extraneous to the purpose of Easter than Santa is to Christmas," Mohler says. "At least Santa Claus was based on a saint. I wonder whether even some Christian churches are making the connection between Christ's death and resurrection and victory over sin — the linchpin doctrine of Christianity."
FIND MORE STORIES IN: California | Houston | God | Phoenix | Christmas | Louisville | Christians | Jesus | Easter | Paul | Christianity | Pope Benedict XVI | Santa Claus | Larry King | Ventura | Escondido | Creator | Southern Baptist Theological Seminary | Joel Osteen | Lakewood Church | Your Best Life Now | Ron Sellers | Barna Research | Ellison Research | Rev. Albert Mohler

Take it from pollsters.

A new survey by Ellison Research in Phoenix finds 87% of U.S. adults believe in the existence of sin, which is defined as "something that is almost always considered wrong, particularly from a religious or moral perspective."

Topping the list are adultery (81%) and racism (74%).

But other sins no longer draw majority condemnation. Premarital sex? Only 45% call it sin. Gambling? Just 30% say it's sinful.

"A lot of this is relative. We tend to view sin not as God views it, but how we view it," says Ellison president Ron Sellers.

David Kinnaman, president of Barna Research, a company in Ventura, Calif., that tracks Christian trends, draws a similar conclusion: "People are quick to toe the line on traditional thinking" that there is sin "but interpret that reality in a very personal and self-congratulatory manner" — I have to do what's best for me; I am not as sinful as most.

Indeed, 65% of U.S. adults say they will go to heaven, and only 0.05% believe they'll go to hell, according to a 2003 Barna telephone survey of 1,024 adults.


"They give intellectual assent to the story about Jesus rising on Easter Sunday: 75% say they believe the biblical account of Jesus' death and resurrection is literally true, not a story meant to illustrate a principle. But they don't have any personal application of this Monday through Saturday," Kinnaman says.

Popular evangelist Joel Osteen, pastor of Lakewood Church in Houston, never mentions sin in his TV sermons or best sellers such as Your Best Life Now.

"I never thought about (using the word 'sinners'), but I probably don't," Osteen told Larry King in an interview. "Most people already know what they're doing wrong. When I get them to church, I want to tell them that you can change."

The Rev. Michael Horton, professor of theology at Westminster Seminary in Escondido, Calif., calls this "moral therapy."

"It's changing your lifestyle to receive God's favor," Horton says. "It's not heaven in the hereafter but happiness here and now. But it is still up to you to make it happen."

He finds sad truth in an old newspaper headline he once saw: " 'To hell with sin when being good is enough.' That's the drift of American preaching today in a lot of churches. People know what sin is; they just don't believe in it anymore. We mix up happiness and holiness, and God is no longer the reference point."

In other words, he asks, if you can solve your problems or sins yourself, what difference does it make that Christ was crucified?

People have to see themselves as sinners — ultimately alienated from God and unable to save themselves — for Christ's sacrifice to be essential, Horton says. "(The apostle) Paul didn't see Easter as therapy."

Pope Benedict, in his prayers last week, said, "People who trust in themselves and in their own merits are, as it were, blinded by their own 'I,' and their hearts harden in sin. On the other hand, those who recognize themselves as weak and sinful entrust themselves to God, and from him obtain grace and forgiveness."

Even some people who say sin is real still steer by a compass of "moral pragmatics," not a bright line of absolute truth, Mohler says. "People say, 'I have high moral expectations of myself and others, but I know we are all human so I'm looking for a batting average.'

"We find a comfort zone of morality, a kind of middle-class middle level where we think we are doing well. We cut the grass. We don't double-park. But we ignore the larger issues of sin.

"Instead of violating the law of the Creator, it becomes more a matter of etiquette. … We want our kids to play well in the sandbox and know their place in line. We want people to do things decently and in order. But it's etiquette of morality without the ethics. The end result is that when we do things we wish people wouldn't do, there's no sense of guilt or shame."

Rules have changed

The rise of secular culture also is exerting an influence. More than one in five Americans (22%) say they never go to church, not even on Christmas or Easter. And 12.1% told a new Pew Forum survey they believe "nothing in particular."

They may be without a church, but "most people still have a notion of sin — like bringing cheap wine to parties," jokes Karsen Case, 34, of Reno. "Seriously, you know what sin is when you get a feeling in your gut that something's wrong."

He hasn't been to church in a decade, although he grew up within the conservative Lutheran Missouri Synod. "I would call myself an atheist now," he says. "But I think the Bible has a lot of good stories. And I do connect with the story of Easter, of redemption and rebirth. It tells me you are going to make mistakes, and you will get another chance to do right in the future."

Secular people still believe there's sin, judgment and punishment, says sociologist Barry Kosmin, a research professor in public policy and law and director of the Institute for the Study of Secularism in Society & Culture at Trinity College in Hartford, Conn.

It's just a different list of sinners than religious traditions teach.

"What is unacceptable has changed," Kosmin observes. "Racism and sexual harassment, which were not sins in the past, are now. Adultery and addiction are just bad or sad behavior. And commercial sex is a no, but breaking the bonds of marriage is not.

"Secularism is situational without fundamental, universal rules. Explanations are kosher. Mitigating circumstances, too. But if people are held guilty, the punishment, of course, has to be in this world, not the next. Secular people don't burn in hell, they burn in the court of public opinion."

Self, not sin

Two pastors serving youthful congregations in big cities, long the statistical capitals of secular culture, say they must talk about sin to be true to their calling. They just have to use 21st-century lingo.

Tim Keller of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in Manhattan is a modern-day variation of the circuit-riding preacher. He dashes across Central Park to three different leased locations to serve 5,000 worshipers at five services on Sundays.

When Keller, author of The Reason for God: Belief in an Age of Skepticism, speaks about "sin" to his audiences, which are 70% single and younger than 40, "I use it with lots and lots of explanation, because the word is essentially obsolete.

"They do get the idea of branding, of taking a word or term and filling it with your own content, so I have to rebrand the word 'sin,' " Keller says.

"Around here it means self-centeredness, the acorn from which it all grows. Individually, that means 'I live for myself, for my own glory and happiness, and I'll work for your happiness if it helps me.' Communally, self-centeredness is destroying peace and justice in the world, tearing the net of interwovenness, the fabric of humanity."

Mark Driscoll says a little talk of hellfire, so out of fashion these days, would do the world good.

Driscoll founded Mars Hill Church in Seattle, a non-denominational megachurch with 7,000 in Sunday attendance, chiefly singles in their 20s.

He defines sin as "anything contrary to God's will. People assume the way they are is normal, not that something has gone terribly wrong, and this world is abnormal."

Although his primary audience is newbie Christians, Driscoll is sharply clear: "Without an idea of sin, Easter is meaningless."

No surprise there...

What are they gonna come up with next? Women wearing tight pants or pants at all is not a sin? Sheesh!

Frankly the concept of sin should have been “left alone” – actually flung into the garbage heap of history along with the religion that was its greatest vehicle – long ago. As it is I do not believe that it is being left alone at all; rather, judging by the fact that the Vatican could issue a whole new list shows how much it is being rejuvenated (to say nothing about the growing fundamentalism that has taken hold of US society and politics)

Of course some bible-waving Imixers are going to recoil at what I say; they always have. It is a testimony to the thoroughness of mental enslavement through Western/Arabic culture MANIFESTED through religious ideas that, in this so-called age of information, we as Caribbean people have done very little research and deconstruction of many religious beliefs that were imposed upon us. Of course the same goes for certain cultural, economic and political assumptions we hold here.

Now me eh want to sound like I on some superior high horse like dat eh, cause I mihself, in spite of rejecting a lot of these beliefs over the years was still jolted as I was researching material for my book recently. Looking at ancient matricentric cultures and cultures that worshipped the concept of a Divine Mother, one of the first things that became apparent was their lack of a concept of sin. To be more preceise, their lack of any elaboration of sin and the idea that mankind is inherently sinful. There is no concept at all of an original sin and piecing together arguments advanced by scholars like Cheikh Anta Diop, Gerda Lerner, Wendell Watters, Barbara G Walker, Marimba Ani and Marilyn French, I realised that this notion of sinfulness in Christian philosophy has very little to do with any god. Rather, it has more to do with a deeply pessimistic and fatalistic ideology that began among patriarchal pre-Christian European tribes in response to the extremely harsh climatic conditions that was their reality many thousands of years ago.

In other words, it is believed, and it is a belief that I share, that this notion of sin is tied into very primitive ideas of what I call the ethic of worthlessness and self-contempt. The hostile wintry climate of ancient Eurasia that saw very little food anywhere, an ever present threat from rival tribes and predatory animals, made every day a literal fight for survival. This led to a collective introspection that was steeped in self-contempt, lack of sentimental attachment to most things and simply became their view of the world around them. This pessimistic view evolved into the solitary, suffering, wandering heroic figure in Greek, Jewish and Christian literature and became the influence for the tragic theme in Greek literature and the valuated ideal of suffering and sinfulness (in constant need of redemption and atonement) in Judaism and Xianity.

Even more serious for us in the Caribbean is the way this concept has been manipulated to maintain passive conformity among exploited persons during enslavement, colonialism and now post-colonialism. But like ah did say, nobody eh discussing nothing, we only unthinkingly accepting and regurgitating certain things like they is foregone conclusions. It eh have no serious culture of reading and critical thinking in the Caribbean (I often feel Trinidad is the worst example of this) and especially when it come to religion. Nothing eh change over the years, only faces and the level of sophistication of religious exploitation. So I’m sorry but my response to the latest list of “sins” is pretty much the same for the old one: Pope/pastor/bishop-whatever, go f**k yuhself.